Why Healthcare’s Next AI Leap Must Go Beyond Chatbots and Point Solutions
Author:
The excitement around artificial intelligence in healthcare has reached a fever pitch. At HLTH this year, the conversation rightly shifted from if AI will impact the healthcare consumer experience to how fast and how profoundly. But for executives grappling with ballooning costs and member attrition, the real — and perhaps more practical — question is: how does AI deliver measurable business value and better health outcomes?
We have reached an inflection point where nearly half of health organizations are now prioritizing the modernization of their digital stacks, and 96% are actively exploring generative AI, according to a new report from League and Healthcare Dive*. But as we look ahead to the next year, the industry faces a critical realization: the promise of AI is currently bottlenecked by foundational challenges that much of the industry is not addressing.
For AI to move from a powerful idea to a proven driver of retention, quality, and cost savings, we must shift our focus from launching pilots to achieving measurable, platform-level outcomes. The next evolution of AI in healthcare must be agentic, purpose-built, platform-based, and hyper-aligned to business value.
The Fragmentation Trap: The Prerequisite for AI Success
The hard truth is that most health plans are attempting to build an AI future on a fragmented foundation. In a survey we recently conducted in partnership with Healthcare Dive, data shows that 58% of payers cite legacy infrastructure as a barrier to CX progress, and 50% are unable to integrate data across their systems. This is bigger than an IT issue. It’s an AI execution barrier.
Why? Because multi-agent “digital teammates” only work when they can see the whole member. If an agent, no matter how intelligent, can only access a fraction of the consumer’s data, their actions will be incomplete, generic, or potentially unsafe. Knowing this, it’s clear that fixing fragmentation is the prerequisite for outcomes, not just a nicer user experience.
This is a major challenge with point solutions. Nearly half (46%) of organizations report their digital stack is only “somewhat integrated.” You cannot deliver an n-of-1, hyper-personalized journey when your data is held together with tape. A unified platform layer is required to normalize data and deliver experiences end-to-end, acting as the necessary orchestrator for the entire health journey.
The Outcome Gap: Moving Beyond Activity to Impact
The industry is rapidly embracing agentic AI — 73% are piloting or assessing it. Yet, there is a concerning chasm between activity and impact. A significant majority of organizations (81%) are evaluating AI ROI, but only a small fraction (27%) can fully tie that investment to tangible CX outcomes.
The challenge is not in the technology, it's in the application. Without outcome alignment, AI pilots won't translate into closed care gaps, lower cost-to-serve, or retention gains. Our window to truly differentiate is not the launch of another pilot, but in the execution, scaling the right nudges at the right time.
To close this gap, organizations must:
Demand Context: Generic LLMs lack the contextual knowledge and require massive effort to tune for compliance and complex actions safely. Healthcare requires purpose-built, compliant AI (HITRUST/HIPAA) built on decades of real-world interactions. The data must be transformed into a dynamic, longitudinal, and plain-language narrative that captures the human context and emotional drivers necessary for deep personalization.
Define High-Value Actions: You must define high-value actions upfront and instrument them. Otherwise, ROI reviews reward activity, not impact. Leaders want higher retention, better clinical outcomes, and cost reduction. Every AI initiative must be tied to one of these primary levers, and the metric must be instrumented on day one.
The Leap to Orchestrated Agent Teams
If we look at the biggest consumer pain points, payers say they are access to care (44%) and communication/outreach (42%). These are complex, multi-step workflows that a simple chatbot, which only answers questions, can never solve.
The next evolution is the deployment of orchestrated agent teams — multi-agent systems that move beyond conversational AI to operational AI at scale. These agents must securely leverage deep context from a comprehensive data asset to execute complex actions on behalf of the member 24/7, such as:
Benefits Navigation to autonomously handle common coverage questions and reduce costly call center volume.
Care Navigation to guide a member to the right in-network specialist and handle logistics like scheduling, ensuring network utilization.
Care Gaps to proactively provide personalized recommendations and resources, leading to improved outcomes and better quality scores (HEDIS/Star Ratings).
This requires an intelligent orchestration layer that prioritizes and delegates these actions. It takes the substantial spend already allocated to core digital assets like member portals (73%) and personalization platforms (55%) and converts them into high-engagement, low-cost actions that move hard KPIs. A modern platform solution, such as League, is specifically designed to provide this missing orchestration layer, seamlessly converting complexity into unified, proactive action. It is the architecture required to deliver on the full promise of agentic AI.
Ultimately, the goal is to create an infinitely powerful, 24/7 care team that transforms fragmented health journeys into adaptive, n-of-1 experiences. For health plan executives, the window is closing: the imperative is no longer to launch a siloed AI pilot within an already fragmented ecosystem, but to deploy unified, compliant infrastructure that powers agentic execution and ties every interaction directly to a measurable outcome.
*Statistics are sourced from a market survey developed in partnership with Healthcare Dive.